Scientists Compared Mormon DNA to America — What They Found Surprised Them

In 1984, a team of researchers affiliated with the University of Utah published a study in the American Journal of Human Genetics that compared the blood of Utah Mormons with a single United States sample, thirteen European populations, and seven religious communities. The authors were Thomas McLellan, Lynn Jorde, and Mark Skolnick. More than four decades later, the results still echo through population genetics, genealogy, and medicine. The central finding was striking in its simplicity: after more than a century in the American West, this group remained genetically close to the northern Europeans their ancestors had left behind. Today, DNA from a few dozen of those families sits inside widely used genetic reference panels. More than eleven million people are linked in a database built from their records. So why did this group appear to freeze its genes in time? Why did the Amish, the Hutterites, and the Mennonites drift apart instead? How did a pioneer family tree help locate a breast cancer gene? And what hidden problem does this create for you? The strangest part is not 1984. The story begins with a ship, a loan fund, and a family tree that became a scientific instrument.

To understand what the scientists actually measured, it helps to start smaller than most people expect. The 1984 paper did not sequence genomes, because that was impossible at the time. The researchers looked at gene frequencies, meaning they counted how often certain inherited traits appeared in a population. They examined six red blood cell antigen systems, nine protein systems, and two immune system genes called HLA-A and HLA-B. Think of it as comparing ingredient lists across many recipes. You do not need the full recipe to recognize which kitchen cooked the dish. Then came the comparison. The researchers placed Utah Mormons beside one United States population and thirteen European populations. They also added seven groups from three isolated religious communities: the Amish, the Hutterites, and the Mennonites. The logic was straightforward. Small, closed religious groups tend to drift away from their ancestors. A church community in the Utah desert should have drifted too. It did not. The gene frequencies of Utah Mormons stayed close to their northern European ancestors. Keep that in mind, because the explanation will change how you think about family trees.

A second surprise hides in that same paper. For the European populations, genetic distances derived from blood markers matched real distances on a map quite closely. The farther apart two groups lived, the more their genes differed. DNA, in other words, holds a rough memory of geography. Utah Mormons landed near northern Europe on that map, even though they lived thousands of miles away. A people had crossed an ocean and a continent, and their genetic address had barely changed. Now compare that with the Amish, the Hutterites, and the Mennonites. According to the study, all three groups moved away from their source populations and from one another. The authors attributed this to isolation and random genetic drift. Drift is what happens when a small group passes on its genes by chance. Think of the game of telephone played in a small room. A small error gets repeated and no one is there to correct it. Over generations, the message changes. In a huge, constantly refreshed crowd, those small errors fade. So why did Utah escape drift? The authors named two reasons. First, a very large founding group. Imagine a jar filled with colored marbles. If you scoop out five, the colors will look strange. If you scoop out a thousand, the mix of the jar stays roughly the same. A small founder group gives chance enormous power. A large one does not. Second, a continuous flow of genes. Imagine a bathtub with the drain open. If the faucet keeps running with the same water, the mix never changes. In Utah, new converts kept arriving from the same parts of northern Europe, so the mix stayed familiar.

That continuous flow was not an accident. It was organized, funded, and documented. Between 1840 and roughly 1890, converts left Britain, Denmark, Sweden, Norway, and Germany for Utah. Most were working families: mill workers in Lancashire, Welsh coal miners, and Danish farmers. The first organized sea voyage left Liverpool in June 1840 aboard the ship Britannia, carrying 41 converts, many of them from Preston. Liverpool then became the main gateway for decades. Many Danish families settled together in Sanpete County in central Utah, and the Danish language could still be heard in some congregations into the early twentieth century. To this day, Danish family names are common throughout Sanpete County. That clustering also made record-keeping easy. A second stream was just as important. The early leaders and converts were Americans, most from New England and upstate New York. Brigham Young was born in Vermont in 1801. Joseph Smith was born in Vermont in 1805. Wilford Woodruff was born in Connecticut in 1807. These families reached Utah before the large European immigration waves. Some had very large families, so a single founding couple can now have an enormous number of living descendants. Hold on to that idea. One ancestor repeated across thousands of descendants is exactly what gene hunters dream of. Picture the scene as a historian might see it: a crowded dock in Liverpool, crates stacked high, and families preparing for weeks at sea bound for a valley their eyes had never seen. This was not a flow of random travelers. It was closer to a pipe, and the pipe left a trail. The ships carried people from the same missions, the same congregations, and often the same regions. Scientists would later read that trail in blood, and then in DNA.

Here is the loan fund that made the pipe work. In 1849, Brigham Young established the Perpetual Emigration Fund. It was a revolving loan. Poor converts in Europe borrowed the money for their passage and repaid it after settling in Utah. Repayments then helped finance the next group. It moved thousands of people, and it moved them through the same channels, from the same mission regions, along the same routes. A river that keeps its banks stays the same river. That is what the fund did to the gene pool in Utah without anyone planning it. Then the flow slowed. Utah became a state in 1896. Around that time, the church began encouraging converts to stay in their home countries and build local congregations. Large organized emigration from Europe faded. So the gene pool in Utah largely stopped receiving big waves from northern Europe. Meanwhile, the rest of America was about to change. That contrast sets up the next discovery, which is stranger than the first. Consider what happened to the rest of the country. Italians, Greeks, and eastern Europeans arrived in large numbers in the early twentieth century. After 1965, more came from Latin America, Asia, and every other continent. Each wave added new threads to one huge, blended fabric. The Utah pool, by contrast, had been filled mostly from northern Europe. That difference is why the 1984 results matter. But what happened next in a Paris laboratory turned this curiosity into a global tool.

The tool began with a big idea in 1980. David Botstein, Ray White, Mark Skolnick, and Ronald Davis proposed using small spelling differences in DNA as markers to map genes across families. Notice Skolnick’s name again. From 1980 to 1984 and on to 1994, the same Utah scientist keeps appearing, which makes this story feel less like coincidence and closer to a very long chase. In the early 1980s, White and his colleagues needed families to build the first maps of the human genome. The best families were large ones with many children and living grandparents, because you can watch genes pass through three generations. Utah had those families, and Utah had the records. In 1984, the French Nobel laureate Jean Dausset founded the CEPH center in Paris to share the DNA of these families with laboratories around the world. The full set grew to 61 families. Forty-seven of them were from Utah. That is the majority. Why did scientists need large families? Imagine a long road with no house numbers. DNA is that road. Genes that sit close together on it tend to travel together from parents to children, like neighbors who always ride in the same car. By watching markers and traits travel together across three generations, scientists could number the road. The method is called linkage mapping. It placed signposts on every chromosome long before anyone could read a full genome. And the same trick was about to track a cancer-causing gene. But first, return to the reference panel that made Utah famous. Why does anyone need a reference panel at all? Here is the idea. Any two unrelated people share about 99.5 percent of their DNA. The differences sit at specific points. The International HapMap Project set out to catalog common variations, versions that appear in at least one percent of people. It sampled four populations: Yoruba families from Ibadan in Nigeria, Japanese individuals from Tokyo, Han Chinese from Beijing, and residents of Utah with northern and western European ancestry. That last group traces directly back to the 1984 study and the families recruited through church records. The Utah sample became a standard against which millions of people around the world are now compared. This is where the hidden problem appears. When a company tells you that you are 60 percent British or 20 percent Scandinavian, it is measuring your DNA against reference panels. If one panel is unusually homogeneous, descended from a large but narrow founding stock, it can sharpen some signals and blur others. Traits and variants that are common in that panel may look more significant than they are. Variants that are rare in it may be missed. Researchers call this panel bias, and it is one reason scientists keep pushing to diversify the reference sets they use. The Utah families gave genetics one of its most productive tools. They also left a reminder that every reference panel is a snapshot of a particular history, not a universal standard. The 1984 paper measured blood groups and proteins, not genomes. Its authors described drift and gene flow, not destiny. What they found was not that one group was special, but that history leaves patterns in DNA, and that a funded migration pipeline, a large founding population, and meticulous records can preserve those patterns for generations. The strangest part, perhaps, is how ordinary the explanation turns out to be: ships, loans, ledgers, and large families, all recorded so carefully that a pioneer family tree became a scientific instrument used by millions of people who have never heard the names McLellan, Jorde, or Skolnick.

Related Posts

I Provided Food for a Sasquatch for 40 Years, and I Understand Why It Fears and Avoids Us – Sasquatch Story

For four decades, a woman living alone in a remote cabin in the Pacific Northwest mountains has kept a secret that challenges everything most people believe about…

New Evidence in the Albert Ostman Bigfoot Abduction Case

The Albert Ostman case has long occupied a peculiar place in the literature of North American Sasquatch reports: frequently cited, widely doubted, and never entirely dismissed. Ostman,…

New Bigfoot Encounter Reported That Left Experts Surprised

A newly circulated report from the Bigfoot Field Research Organization has reignited public fascination with Sasquatch lore after a witness described a tall, dark, human-like figure crossing…

Archaeologists Reported a Possible Bigfoot Settlement Deep in the Rockies; Authorities Restricted Access – Story

The story began, as such stories often do, with a promise kept for decades and a secret that had waited long enough. For more than thirty years,…

3 Hours of Bigfoot Encounters That Remain Unexplained

The 2013 footage near the Tennessee–Georgia border remains one of the most widely discussed clips in the long-running debate over Bigfoot, the large, upright primate-like figure said…

Farmer Reported a Dogman Inside His Barn; What Was Found by Morning Was Disturbing

Arthur Denney, a 67-year-old cattle farmer in Elkton, Kentucky, had spent two decades keeping a loaded Remington 870 on two pegs above his mudroom coat rack, and…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *