The longline fleet that worked the outer edge of the Brazilian continental shelf off Recife in the summer of 1993 came home over five days and did not go back out. It did not happen all at once, as was customary, but boat by boat, until the port of Natal filled with a fleet that was supposed to be at sea. The manager of the fishing cooperative came to the docks asking questions the skippers did not answer directly. The fishing grounds they had abandoned were among the most productive in the South Atlantic. Yellowfin tuna and bigeye tuna were in their spawning season. Swordfish were present at the edge. By every standard the men used to judge a fishing season, it was exactly the wrong time to return. And yet they returned. The cooperative manager filed a complaint with IBAMA, the Brazilian environmental agency, asking whether the outer areas had been closed by regulation without announcement. IBAMA confirmed that this had not happened. The manager went back to the docks. The skippers told him the fish had left. The fish had not left. Satellite data showed that tuna were still concentrated at the outer edge above the São Paulo Ridge, and the skippers knew that as well as anyone. Yet they did not go back to sea.
The man who could have clarified the matter for the cooperative manager is named Gilberto Assunção. He is from Natal, from a family of fishermen in the Redinha neighborhood on the north bank of the Potengi River, where fishing boats have always docked. He was 36 years old in 1993 and is now 69, still living in Redinha and walking to the river every morning. Not to fish, but simply to look at the water, something he says is different from fishing in a way that took him years to understand. “When you fish, you are asking something of the water,” he says. “When you just look at it, you are not asking for anything.” He stopped asking things of the deep water in 1993, and it took him a long time to realize that what he was doing when he went to look at it every morning was something different. He was checking, making sure it was still there, making sure that the thing he saw there in 1993 had gone back to where it came from and stayed there. He says this in the shade of the porch of his house in Redinha, where the river appears at the end of the street and the smell of the estuary hangs in the air. He is a large, quiet man who weighs his words the way one weighs something of limited supply. He told the story once to his wife in 1995, two years after it happened, and she listened to him and said nothing for a long time, then said: “Don’t tell the children.” And he never did. The children are now adults with lives of their own, and they know that their father stopped fishing in deep water in 1993, and they have not asked why, because his face carries the answer to that question before it is spoken. He decided to tell me because a man he trusts told him that I was collecting these accounts, that they would be added to others from other coasts and other waters, and that what he saw would not remain alone in what I write, which matters to him in a way he found difficult to explain, and in the end did not try to explain, saying only: “I want to know that I was not alone.” He was not alone.

But let me take you to the water first. The Brazilian continental shelf along the northeast coast, in the Natal and Recife region, and the great bulge of the South American continent into the Atlantic Ocean, is a specific kind of shelf: wide in places, narrow in others, and fertile in the shallow areas, but with deep-water terrain whose character changes rapidly as one moves away from shore. The outer shelf edge descends into the deep western South Atlantic basin, the Brazil Basin, which reaches depths of more than 5,000 meters and extends southward from the tropical Atlantic along the eastern edge of South America. The Brazil Basin is one of the least-studied deep-ocean environments in the Atlantic. The biology of its bottom is largely unknown. The structure of its deep currents is complex, and the upwelling that the current creates along the shelf edge is what drives the exceptional productivity of the outer areas where the longline fleet worked. At the latitude of Natal, the shelf edge lies about 200 to 300 kilometers from shore. Behind it, the floor slopes down toward the Brazil Basin, and at the coordinates where Gilberto was working in July 1993, the landmark directly beneath the outer areas is the São Paulo Ridge. The São Paulo Ridge is an underwater system of elevations that rises from the deep floor of the Brazil Basin and in some places comes within a few hundred meters of the surface. It is a large topographic feature, running roughly east to west, and the interaction between the ridge’s terrain and the deep basin currents creates a complex hydrographic environment at the shelf edge above it. Upwelling, thermal gradients, and biological aggregations. The tuna know where the shelf is, just as tuna know every fertile edge in the ocean, and the fleet knew where the tuna were because they were above the shelf, and the shelf was where the deep areas produced. Beneath the shelf lies the deep basin. The São Paulo Ridge rises from water that in other places reaches depths of 3,000 or 4,000 meters. This landmark is itself a topographic anomaly, a raised structure surrounded on all sides by cold deep water. Everything the deep basin holds has access to the ridge from every direction. The ridge is, topographically, a prominence, something raised, a place that climbs from the depths and comes closer to the surface than the ocean floor around it, a natural platform, and a place where the depths can reach the continental shelf from below.
It is midday. Gilberto tells the story the way all these men tell the true account, without affectation. While he looked at the river at the end of the street instead of looking at me, he was working the outer edge above the ridge in the early afternoon. The sun was high, visibility was good, and the sea had manageable swells coming from the southeast. His gear was in the water, a long line set in the deep, and he was waiting on it the way longlining requires, the patient wait of a man who has put his gear in the right place and need only keep to the schedule. His depth sounder was running at the depth of the outer areas above the São Paulo Ridge. The device was mapping the structure of the ridge beneath him, the terrain of the raised landmark in the water column under the boat. He knew these marks. He had fished above the ridge many times, and he knew how the ridge appeared on the sonar. The familiar shapes of the landmark that told him he was in the right place. The marks changed, not the ridge. The ridge was still there, the steady topographic echo unchanged. But above the ridge, in the water column between the ridge and the boat, something appeared that had not been there before. A large echo, biological in character, the acoustic quality with the soft edges of a living mass rather than rock or sediment. Rising, coming up from the ridge toward the surface, slowly, with the steady vertical motion of something ascending under its own will. He watched it for about three minutes before it registered. What he was looking at was not a school of fish, not a whale, not a density layer. Its shape did not fit any of those things, and it was rising at a speed unlike that of a drifting mass, and unlike the speed of an animal fleeing. It was rising the way something rises when it is headed somewhere. He was still looking at the sonar when his assistant called him from the stern on deck. The assistant’s name was Marcelo. He was 22 years old, and this was his second season in deep water. He called once, in a voice that was not raised, the voice that Gilberto says he has heard before from young men who have seen something they have no name for. A voice tightly controlled, because the alternative to that control is not something a young man wishes to discover about himself in front of others. Gilberto came out of the wheelhouse. The water behind the stern was moving in the wrong direction. “I know what waves do, and I know what wind does to the surface, and I know what the edge of a current looks like when you cross it,” he says. But the water behind my stern was doing none of that. It was rising in a smooth, long pattern, a line of raised water running from south to north, passing behind the boat, and the rise came from below. A displacement of something, something massive in the water beneath the surface pushing the water above it upward as it moved north, and the pushed water was what I was seeing. A long, low edge on the surface traced the passage of what was below. The displacement passed behind the stern and continued on its way north.
He went to the stern rail and looked. The water to the north of the boat, in the direction the displacement had traveled, had changed. The surface had a quality he found hard to describe, and he settled on describing it as “inhabited,” not disturbed, but inhabited, the way a room is inhabited when someone is in it, even if you do not see them directly. The water had weight. A presence. Then the fin broke the surface. He has spent 30 years with this moment, and he tells it carefully, a man who has handled something fragile for a very long time and knows exactly how it breaks. The fin rose from the inhabited water about 40 meters north of his boat. It rose slowly, not in an explosion, not as the sudden appearance of an animal that surfaces quickly, but with a deliberate emergence, the way a submarine’s tower rises when it ascends without haste. It rose until it stood above the surface at a height he estimates, comparing it to the height of his boat’s side above the water, the visual geometry of distance, and his knowledge of what a meter looks like in open water after 30 years of working in it, at between two and two and a half meters. He is precise about this estimate, and he holds to it, and he will not revise it in either direction. A triangular fin, like the fin of a great white shark. He has fished for great whites on this coast throughout his career. He knows this shape.

What he saw next he describes without drama, in the flat manner of a man reporting measurements. The fin was not attached to a body that matched it. Behind the fin, at the distance he could see, the water showed no corresponding mass, no back breaking the surface, no tail. The fin moved north, slowly, and the displacement moved with it, and the water above it stayed inhabited. He watched for a time he does not specify precisely, because he says he stopped counting, and then the fin went down. It did not dive. It descended, the way it had risen, deliberately, and the inhabited quality of the water went with it, and the surface returned to the surface. Marcelo had not spoken. Gilberto went back into the wheelhouse and looked at the sonar. The large biological echo was gone from the water column. The ridge was still there. The steady topographic echo was unchanged. He hauled his gear, which took the rest of the afternoon, and he did not set it again. He took the boat in. He did not tell the cooperative manager what he had seen, and he did not tell the other skippers, and he did not need to, because they had seen their own versions of it, and that is why the fleet came home boat by boat and did not go back out. The official record of the 1993 season in Natal does not contain the word shark. It contains a fleet that returned early from productive grounds, a cooperative manager’s unanswered questions, and an IBAMA confirmation that no closure had been declared. What it does not contain is the reason. Gilberto Assunção is 69 now, and he walks to the Potengi every morning to look at the water, and he says he is checking that the thing he saw in 1993 went back to where it came from and stayed there. He told me his story because he wants to know that he was not alone. He was not alone. Along the same coast, in the same years, other men came home early from grounds that were producing, and gave the same answers when asked why, and did not go back out, and did not tell the children.
Report
Report this article
×
Select a reason for reporting:
