The Port San Luis Harbor District confirmed this week that four pilings were torn from beneath the Avila pier on Saturday, November 14, and that seven pilings in total were damaged, according to reporting by the San Luis Obispo Tribune. Roughly 140 miles up the California coast, the same long-period swell struck the Capitola wharf in Santa Cruz County, breaking deck boards and railings and damaging two of the support piles that hold the structure above the water. The timing is difficult for Capitola in particular: the city rebuilt that wharf for $10.6 million and reopened it just 26 months ago, and officials now find themselves inspecting the same landmark for structural damage once again.

The weekend produced a broad pattern of closures and flooding rather than a single isolated incident. Offshore near Cape San Martin, the swell measured almost 28 feet, while a Harbor Patrol officer in Morro Bay estimated breaking waves there at 15 to 20 feet. About 2,000 people came out to watch the surf, and water ran into the parking lot at Morro Rock. Pismo Beach closed its pier through Sunday morning with waves of 15 to 18 feet forecast to crash onto the deck, the Cayucos pier closed as well, and at Port San Luis waves pushed water into a parking lot and threw rocks and debris near the Harford Pier. In Southern California, piers closed over the weekend in Ventura, Manhattan Beach, Hermosa Beach, Huntington Beach, and Pacific Beach in San Diego. Manhattan Beach described its closure as a rare move, and in Seal Beach several inches of seawater covered the strand and flooded beachfront homes, where residents reported seeing restaurants near the ocean boarded up with sandbags around the businesses.

Capitola’s experience on Saturday carried a painful sense of repetition. Around 12:30 p.m., close to high tide, video from a local bait shop showed waves crashing into the wharf and tearing at the railing. City officials said the swells damaged deck boards, railings, and two support piles, and the wharf is closed while crews repair it and engineers check for structural damage. Waves also washed out the bottom of the Hoopers Beach ramp, flooded the Riverview path, and piled sand against the beachfront homes on Venetian Court. The Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office had issued an evacuation warning the night before for Capitola Village and nearby beach neighborhoods from New Brighton down to Rio Del Mar. In January 2023, storms washed away the middle of this same wharf; the rebuild was designed to be tougher and wider, with more pilings and new pilings that can be raised as the sea rises, and it reopened in September 2024. Twenty-six months later, the ocean was back on the deck.

The obvious question is how large these waves actually were, and the answer complicates the simplest explanation for the damage. Off Point Reyes, a buoy measured 31.2 feet on Saturday, the highest reading at that buoy since 2015. At Mavericks, the National Weather Service said waves reached 50 to 60 feet. Yet the record off this coast is far higher: during the El Niño of 2015 and 2016, a buoy off Mendocino measured more than 63 feet, and one off Point Reyes measured 55 feet in December 2015. The weekend’s surf was therefore smaller than waves this coastline has already absorbed. What has changed is the baseline beneath them. Between October 24 and 30, driven mostly by unusually high tides, gauges in San Diego, La Jolla, Los Angeles, and Santa Barbara all recorded the highest water levels ever measured there. San Diego reached 2.8 feet above its average high tide, and in Huntington Beach a tide on Tuesday, October 27, reached 8.2 feet, a new local record. Seawater poured into Sunset Beach and Huntington Harbor, 114 homes and other buildings took on water, six were yellow tagged, and the city declared a local emergency.

Federal scientists point to the same underlying mechanism. NOAA’s National Ocean Service says El Niño can lift sea level along the coast by 6 to 12 inches or more for weeks at a time, and in San Francisco tides have run about a foot above predictions since early October. US coastal engineer Costa Synolakis says this winter’s waves do not need to match the giants of 1983 to cause the same kind of damage, because the sea is already sitting higher, and he notes that back-to-back storms are the most damaging of all because beaches get no time to rebuild between them. When the whole ocean sits a foot higher, a wave of the same size climbs higher up every piling and closer to the deck. The damaged-pier list was already long before this weekend. Just before Christmas 2024, in a different storm, about 150 feet of the end of the Santa Cruz wharf collapsed into the ocean, part of a section already marked for repair; three city workers went into the water and all three got out. The same day, a man was killed at Sunset State Beach when a wave trapped him under debris. In Ventura, a December swell a year earlier wiped out or damaged 19 pilings on a pier first built in 1872. In San Diego, the Ocean Beach pier has been battered since 2019 and the city has been planning a replacement, and in Pacifica the municipal pier has been closed since June 4 of this year after city workers found cracks separating concrete and movement near where it meets the land. On November 14, waves broke over the Beach Boulevard seawall at the midday high tide, and a concrete plate near Salada Avenue lifted and buckled overnight.

Forecasters warn that the weekend may not be the end of it, and the setup this week differs from the last. Saturday’s waves were born far away in a storm with hurricane-force winds near the Gulf of Alaska. This week, the storm itself comes ashore Tuesday night and Wednesday with rain, strong wind, and gales offshore, and forecasters say storm-force gusts are possible along the Big Sur coast Wednesday into Thursday. The Los Angeles office of the National Weather Service expects another large swell from late Wednesday into Thursday, possibly big enough for a high surf warning, then even larger surf on Thursday and Friday, November 19 and 20. On the Central Coast, high surf advisories are already running through early Wednesday with breakers of 12 to 18 feet in San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara counties; Ventura beaches face 8 to 12 feet, and in Orange and San Diego counties the advisory calls for 6 to 10 feet on west-facing beaches with minor coastal flooding at high tide. NOAA expects above-normal high tides again from November 22 to 27, the next window when the sea sits highest, followed by the king tides of late December. For accuracy, no pier on this coast collapsed this weekend: the Avila pier lost pilings, the Capitola wharf is closed for repairs, and Pismo Beach reopened its pier on Sunday morning. But the Avila pier in San Luis Obispo County has been partly closed since 2015, work was already underway to repair and strengthen it before this winter, and ahead of what could be a significant El Niño the pier closed on Friday, a day before the surf arrived. Losing pilings is not new there either; in January 2023 a storm took three of them, and the Harbor District’s facilities manager, Chris Munson, said at the time that the pier usually loses a few pilings in large storms and was holding up for now. This time four were pulled out and seven damaged in a single swell before the rainy season has really begun, which is why officials and residents along the coast are watching the next set of tide tables as closely as the surf forecast.