A Sperm Whale Washed Ashore in New Zealand in 1994 — With Bite Marks No Known Shark Could Explain

In August 1994, an adult male sperm whale stranded on the beach of Mahia Peninsula on the east coast of New Zealand’s North Island. This is not unusual in itself. Whales strand. It is a tragedy and a biological event, one that the Department of Conservation responds to, that scientists attend, that measurements are taken at, that a cause of death is determined as best it can be, that a record is preserved, and that the sea keeps its secrets about. What made the Mahia stranding different was what was on the whale when it came ashore. Dr. Susan Fairweather, a marine biologist who was then working at the National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research in Wellington, was part of the response team. She is now retired, living in Nelson at the top of the South Island, and she agreed to speak with me on the condition that I report her comments accurately and do not attribute to her any conclusion she did not reach. She is a precise scientist, and retirement has not dulled that precision.

She says: “I have examined a great many stranded cetaceans over the course of my career. The bite patterns of known shark species on cetacean carcasses are well understood. What was on the Mahia whale was not consistent with any known shark species in a way I could explain, and I have spent 30 years being troubled by it.” She said it the way a scientist says the thing that has bothered her the longest—plainly, without drama, in the flat tone of a person who has stopped hoping the trouble will go away. Let me take you to the animal first, because the whale matters, and the specific nature of what was found on it matters, and without both together the story remains only a claim. The whale was a mature male, estimated at 16 meters in length, and in reasonable physical condition before whatever happened to it happened. It had not been dead long when it reached the shore. The stranding team reached it within hours, and the examination was conducted under reasonable conditions—relevant because the state of a carcass affects the clarity of wound patterns—and the Mahia whale was clearly marked.

Illustration 1

A great white shark, an adult female measuring 5 to 6 meters, produces a bite arc width in cetacean tissue of approximately 40 to 60 centimeters. The largest bite arc widths ever measured from confirmed great white predation events in the scientific literature are under 80 centimeters. The wound on the Mahia whale was 1.8 meters across. She reflects on this for a moment and says: “You are looking at a jaw that closed on 1.8 meters of tissue. To produce a bite arc of that width, you need a jaw with a corresponding span. The scaling relationship between jaw width and body length in lamnid sharks—the family that includes the great white—is reasonably well established. A jaw producing a bite arc 1.8 meters wide implies a body length I will not give you a specific number for because the measurement carries uncertainties, but it does not correspond to any known shark species currently living.” I ask her what it corresponds to, then. She is silent for a moment. She says: “It corresponds to a lamnid shark considerably larger than any lamnid shark alive in the scientific record. By ‘considerably larger,’ I mean by a factor that places it outside the range of anything currently accepted as a living animal.” She pauses. “I want to be very clear about what I am saying and what I am not saying. I am saying that the dimensions of the wounds found on the Mahia whale are not consistent with any known living shark. I am not saying I know what caused them. Those are two different statements, and I will not collapse the first into the second.”

The tooth traces—this is the other part. Within three of the seven wound sites, what she describes as tooth drag marks were found: longitudinal scratches in the tissue caused by tooth tips during jaw closure and head shaking, which is how lamnid sharks feed. The great white bites, holds, and shakes its head. The teeth leave parallel longitudinal scratches in the tissue as it is dragged through during that motion. The spacing between these scratches—the distance between the parallel lines—gives you the distance between the teeth that made them. Tooth spacing scales with jaw size, and jaw size scales with body length. The spacing between the tooth drag marks in the Mahia whale wounds was approximately 4 centimeters between each line. The tooth spacing of a great white shark 5 to 6 meters in length is approximately 1 to 2 centimeters, not 4 centimeters. That is more than double the tooth spacing of the largest great white shark known to be alive. Susan documented all of this. She photographed it, measured it, recorded it in the stranding report, and submitted it to the National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research and the Department of Conservation. The stranding report is in the Department of Conservation archive. She showed me her personal field notes from the examination—handwritten, with measurements in columns and a series of precise illustrations of the wound sites annotated with arc widths and tooth spacings. The handwriting is very steady. The measurements are what they are. She submitted the report and it was archived, and no one followed up, and no one asked her about it, and the whale was handled in the usual way, and the stranding was recorded as cause of death undetermined—the accurate description when a cause of death is not in fact determined—and the file was closed. She says: “I expected someone to ask about the dimensions of the bite. No one did. I have sometimes wondered whether that was because no one read the report carefully, or because someone read it carefully and decided they had no category for it and set it aside.” Both explanations are possible, and neither is satisfying. She kept the file and got on with her life. She has kept thinking about it for 30 years.

And now the history, because it is shorter here and more specific, and it belongs close to the whale. The Maori people of the east coast of the North Island have a relationship with sperm whales going back to the settlement of New Zealand—about 800 years, perhaps more. The sperm whale appears in the oral traditions of the coastal tribes, not merely as a resource but as a being of significance, a creature whose stranding is an event that carries meaning, and whose deep-water behaviors are understood in ways that were not entirely erased by the arrival of European science. Raymond Tuhou, a sonar technician from Kaiday, whose account of the Kermadec contact appears elsewhere in this series, knows these traditions. When I told him about the Mahia whale, without mentioning the details of the bite wounds, he was silent for a moment and then said: “Where on the animal’s body?” I answered: “On the posterior ventral surface, from below and behind.” He said: “That is the attack geometry of something larger than the whale. Something that comes from below and bites upward. Something the whale cannot defend itself against because it is outside the range of its defense. A sperm whale can fight with its jaws and its tail. Below and behind is where you go if you are large enough that you do not need to worry about the jaws and the tail.” I asked him whether this is mentioned in the traditions. He said: “What appears in the traditions is that sperm whales are sometimes found bearing marks from something that should have been capable of injuring them. Not from orcas, which leave different wounds, but from something that comes from depths deeper than the whale reaches and follows it upward. The whale dives to two thousand meters for squid. The thing that follows it up comes from deeper than that.” He said this carefully, then added: “I do not know whether what I am telling you is science or just a story. In my traditions, the two are not always different, but I am telling you what was passed to me, and what was passed to me says that the sperm whales in the deep water east of this coast sometimes bear marks that the old people understood as evidence of something in the depths larger than a sperm whale that hunts them from below.” Something that comes from depths deeper than the whale reaches and follows it upward. The Mahia whale came ashore with wounds on its posterior ventral surface from something that approached from below and behind with a jaw 1.8 meters across and teeth spaced 4 centimeters apart. Let me set the science aside, because it is unusually direct in this case. Sperm whales are themselves among the largest predators that have ever existed. An adult male 16 meters long is not a small animal, and it is not easily injured. The principal predators of sperm whales are killer whales, which attack in groups from multiple directions, and large sharks, which typically scavenge weakened animals rather than attack healthy adults.

Illustration 2

Report

Report this article
×

Select a reason for reporting:

Illustration 3

Related Posts

A Deep-Sea Camera Recorded an Animal Following a Blue Whale at 3,000 Feet

The hydrophone picked up the heartbeat first. That detail matters because it establishes the sequence of events with unusual clarity. The recording came from a deep research…

Fishermen Off South Africa Reported a Large Shark Following Orcas in 1997 — It Was Longer Than Their Boat

The longline fleet that worked the outer edge of the Brazilian continental shelf off Recife in the summer of 1993 came home over five days and did…

Researchers Off Norway Observed a Shark Approach a Pod of Orcas in 1998 — The Orcas Dispersed

In November 1998, a Norwegian research vessel conducting a herring survey in a fjord in northern Norway documented a highly unusual encounter: a large, dark animal surfaced…

Cage Divers Off Mexico Reported a Second Shark Beside an 18-Foot Great White in 2004

In the autumn of 2004, underwater cameraman Russ Hartley was filming an eighteen-foot great white shark through the bars of a dive cage off Guadalupe Island, Mexico,…

9 Minutes That Will Change How You View Tiger Sharks

The moment a fifteen-foot tiger shark lunged at diver Steven Sim during a Fiji expedition on May 17, 2019, the underwater world stopped being a controlled thrill…

A Deep-Sea Camera Recorded a Great White Shark at 2,000 Feet

The camera at 2,000 feet caught the great white shark pressed against the rock, and it was not moving. That single frame, recovered from a deep-water research…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *