In the final week of August 1943, in an olive grove near Randazzo on the island of Sicily, three thousand American infantrymen were about to learn the strangest thing about General George S. Patton. A thick cloud of dust rose among the trees, and inside it was the general’s command car. Patton climbed onto a platform, and an infantry major named Theodore Conway, standing among the ranks, heard the voice he would describe years later to a military interviewer. General Patton’s voice was sharp and high-pitched. The general said, “Sit down,” and the men sat on their steel helmets. They knew why he was there. He had come to apologize, and he spoke one word: “Men.” What those three thousand did after that word is recorded, and we will return to this grove, because the apology had a cause: two medical tents and a soldier from Mishawaka, Indiana, who had been struck in the face. That soldier lived another twenty-seven years. Before he died, he spoke one sentence about George Patton, and of all the things generals have written about this man, that sentence is the one I return to again and again. But to understand its weight, you have to stand where the men around him stood. The drivers, the aides, the nurses, the men he punished—all of them faced the same strange things. The voice, the mirror, the neckties, the pistols, the other lives he claimed to have lived, and the crying that no one expected at all. Three things must be kept in mind before we begin. The first is the public image. By the time of the events of this battle, Patton had just won the race to Messina. Thirty-eight days of fighting across Sicily ended with his Seventh Army reaching the city ahead of the British. The newspapers called him “Old Blood and Guts.” The second is the man above him. General Dwight Eisenhower commanded every Allied soldier in the Mediterranean, and he had known Patton since they were young officers. He needed him desperately, and he knew the truth about him. The third is a simple military rule: an officer who strikes an enlisted soldier commits an offense that requires a court-martial. It does not matter whether the officer holds a rank or a higher rank. Remember this rule well.

Now, the first witness, the man who misjudged the man. It is the autumn of 1941. During the maneuvers of the First World War buildup, the United States Army is conducting a test to see whether it is capable of fighting at all. A young reserve lieutenant named Porter Williamson was assigned a task for which he was not prepared. The colonel responsible for armored corps supply had left in a hurry, and Williamson was now responsible for fuel. He had tank cars full of gasoline parked on a railroad siding, and no way to move them to the Second Armored Division. So he went looking for division headquarters. On his way, he found a tank stuck in a stream. Beside it stood a gray-haired sergeant, issuing orders in a sharp, hoarse voice. Williamson approached him. Then the sergeant put on his helmet, and on it were two silver stars. He wanted to know where his fuel was and who was responsible for supply. Williamson answered: I am. Within minutes, the general stopped shouting about gasoline and asked the lieutenant whether he could borrow his map, because he had decided he would enjoy capturing the commander of the other side. The general who would become the most famous American soldier of the war had just been mistaken for a sergeant by a lieutenant of his own corps, because of his appearance without his cap and the tone of his voice when his mouth was open. Williamson was not the only one this happened to. Dwight Eisenhower met Patton just after the First World War at Camp Meade in Maryland. Patton’s biographer, Carlo D’Este, records his astonishment at the contradiction. There was an elegant, impetuous, wealthy cavalryman, and his voice was sharp. Kay Summersby, the Irish woman who drove Eisenhower around England and North Africa, admired Patton greatly. She said he had the manners of a knight and that all he needed was a cloak and a sword. She also wrote that this image of a strong man was distorted by what she called the worst voice in the world. In early 1944 in England, about 250 officers and 750 enlisted men of the new Third Army stood waiting for their first look at their commander. One of the new staff officers wrote home about it. The drums rolled, the trumpets played, and he said there was not a single inch of anyone’s body there that did not feel a chill. Then that huge man in the perfect uniform opened his mouth, and the man wrote down what came out. He said it was a boyish, high-pitched voice. And here lies the real problem, because not everyone agreed. A Third Army historian who watched him at morning briefings confirmed that his voice was sharp but was never shrill or feminine. As he described it, the voice rose by about an octave when Patton lost his temper. So the men who heard him calm heard one voice, and those who heard him angry heard another. You can guess which voice the soldiers usually heard. And Patton knew it. D’Este, who examined the family papers, says Patton considered that voice a curse. In the spring of 1942, he built the huge training camp in the California desert and wired microphones to his office and his tent so that he could interrupt the camp radio whenever he wished. The music would stop suddenly, and that sharp, rough voice would announce: “This is General Patton.” He would fire a colonel on the air, and the soldiers listening in the desert would laugh hard. On other nights, he would announce that he had found an excellent soldier that day and would name him and his unit. So the most self-conscious voice in the army was the same voice that insisted on appearing on the radio night and day. The men found this strange, and they were right, because the voice was only part of something he had been working on his whole life.

There is a photograph Patton mailed to his nephew in 1927 from Hawaii. It shows him scowling. He explained that this was his war face and that he had been practicing it in front of a mirror his whole life. He said he intended to use it again to frighten the Germans. Imagine who is saying this. It is a forty-one-year-old major, married with three children. He is writing to his nephew to tell him he is practicing his scowl. His daughter Ruth Ellen remembered watching him do it. She said he spent hours in front of the mirror. On one occasion she never forgot, he stood there scowling while reciting a speech from Shakespeare’s Henry V, the speech about stiffening the sinews and lending the eye a terrible aspect. Years passed before she discovered the source of those words. She and her sister used to recite the last line to their horses while jumping. So when the soldiers saw his scowl, they were looking at something that had taken decades to form. He told the men in the desert that war was no place for smiling and threatened to shoot anyone caught smiling in a photograph. The records do not indicate whether anyone took that literally. The swearing formed in the same way. The same Third Army historian who attended those morning briefings noticed something the soldiers could never have noticed. He said Patton never used profanity with his staff. He had a few swear words, and that was all. The profanity was, in the historian’s words, mostly to educate the soldiers. Charles Codman was Patton’s aide for more than two years. He accompanied him all the way from Africa to Germany. Codman wrote that throughout that period, he never heard the general tell a dirty story. Think of the most famous speech of the war, the one George C. Scott delivered in front of the giant flag. The aide closest to him never heard the man who delivered it tell a dirty joke. Richard Stillman, a colonel who worked near Patton at Third Army headquarters, put it simply. Stillman said he was an actor, and he admitted he was playing the role. The man who saw the joke more than anyone else was the man who drove the car. Sergeant First Class John Mims drove Patton’s car from Fort Benning, Georgia, through the war. On one of the first mornings, Mims was driving at the posted speed limit of twenty-five miles per hour when Patton told him to speed up. Mims reached thirty-five. A hundred yards later, Patton was shouting at him that if he was afraid to drive the car, he could get out and walk. From then on, Mims drove at eighty-five. Then the storm ends as quickly as it came, as if it had never been. The way the matter was remembered around him makes you wonder how a man could raise all that noise and commotion and then remain calm. In 1944, a cocktail party was held in Nutsford, England, attended by Patton with only Mims. Mims found the kitchen and the drinks, and by the end of the evening he was no longer able to drive. So the three-star general drove his sergeant home. The next morning, for the first time and not the last, Sergeant Mims woke up a private. In the end, as a kindly uncle does, Patton took pity on him and restored his rank. If the anger was acting, then what happened in the hospital tent was impossible. An actor knows when the scene ends. Remember this well, because the verdict will address it directly. But first, there was the matter of what you wore when the acting began. In early March 1943, Patton took command of the American II Corps in Tunisia. Rommel had just forced the corps to retreat through the Kasserine Pass, and its soldiers looked exhausted. Many of them considered Patton’s treatment a form of madness. Omar Bradley, who was about to become his deputy, recorded the details. Every man had to wear his necktie. Every man had to wear tight trousers. Every man had to wear a heavy steel helmet in the desert, in a war of firearms. Officers had to wear their rank insignia on their helmets. Patton believed that discipline in dress produced discipline in combat, and he was not entirely wrong, but the men found the rules bizarre. They also found the pistols bizarre. Patton carried two revolvers with ivory grips, and he wore them even when he was not in the field. He said he wore them because he was a soldier and soldiers carry weapons. The men noticed something else: he wore them in headquarters, at meetings, and in photographs. It was part of the costume, and the costume was part of the message.

The strangest thing of all, perhaps, was the matter of the other lives. Patton claimed to have lived before. He spoke of being a soldier in ancient Carthage, of fighting with the legions of Rome, of standing with Napoleon’s armies, and of dying in battle in previous centuries. He said these things not as a joke but as a settled conviction. He told his nephew about a vision at a battlefield in France where he believed he had fought in a previous life. He told officers on his staff the same things, and they did not know what to make of it. Some thought it was theater, another performance for another audience. Others thought he believed it entirely. D’Este records that Patton’s belief in reincarnation was sincere and lifelong, and that it shaped the way he spoke about death. He told his men that a soldier who died in battle did not truly die, and he seemed to mean it. The men around him found this unsettling. They could follow a commander who shouted and swore and demanded neckties, but a commander who claimed to remember dying in ancient battles was something else. And yet the same man could be unexpectedly tender. There was the crying. No one expected the crying. On the day of the apology at Randazzo, after he spoke the word “Men,” Patton stood before the three thousand and said that he had made a mistake and that he was sorry. He said he had lost his temper and that he had no excuse. The men who had been told to sit on their helmets watched the most famous soldier in the war apologize to them, and some of them cried. Conway, the major who heard the voice, said he had never seen anything like it. The general cried too, or so the witnesses said. The man who had practiced a scowl in the mirror for forty years stood in an olive grove and wept in front of three thousand soldiers. The apology had a cause, and the cause is the part of the story that matters most. Two medical tents. A soldier from Mishawaka, Indiana. In early August 1943, Patton visited a field hospital in Sicily. He walked among the wounded, and he spoke to them. He came to a soldier who was sitting up, and the soldier had no visible wound. Patton asked him what was wrong, and the soldier said something about his nerves. Patton became enraged. He called the soldier a coward, he struck him, and he ordered that he be removed from the hospital. The soldier was Private Charles Kuhl, and he was suffering from what was then called battle fatigue. The incident was not the only one. There was a second hospital visit and a second soldier, and the reports reached Eisenhower. Eisenhower, who needed Patton desperately and who knew the truth about him, did not court-martial him. Instead, he ordered him to apologize to the men he had struck and to the units involved, and he kept him in command. The apology at Randazzo was part of that order. The soldier from Mishawaka was Charles Kuhl, and he lived twenty-seven years after the incident. Before he died, he spoke one sentence about George Patton. He said that Patton was a great general, and that he had been right about him. The sentence is puzzling, and it is the one I return to. Perhaps Kuhl meant that Patton had been right about the war, or right about the necessity of toughness, or right about something else entirely. The record does not explain it, and Kuhl did not elaborate. What the record does show is that the men who served around Patton saw a man who was not one thing. They saw a voice that was sharp and a scowl that was practiced and a profanity that was mostly for show. They saw a commander who demanded neckties in the desert and wept in an olive grove. They saw a man who claimed to remember dying in Carthage and who took pity on his sergeant and restored his rank. The men found all of this unusual, and they were right, because George Patton was not a simple man. He was a performance and a conviction and a temper and a tenderness, and the men who stood closest to him saw all of it. The soldier from Mishawaka saw one part of it, and he said, before he died, that Patton was a great general and that he had been right. The record does not explain the sentence, and perhaps it does not need to. The men who sat on their helmets in the olive grove knew what they had seen, and they remembered it for the rest of their lives.

What the men found most unusual, in the end, was not the voice or the mirror or the pistols. It was the inconsistency. A man who shouted at a sergeant for driving too slowly and then drove that sergeant home from a party. A man who threatened to shoot anyone caught smiling and then cried in front of three thousand soldiers. A man who demanded neckties in the desert and apologized for striking a soldier. The men around him learned to expect the unexpected, and they learned that the performance and the man were not separable. Patton knew this, or he came to know it. He told his staff that he was an actor, and he admitted he was playing a role. But the role was also the man, and the man was also the role, and the men who served under him understood that better than anyone. They found him unusual, and they were right, and they remembered him. The olive grove at Randazzo is gone now, or it has changed, but the record of what happened there remains. Three thousand soldiers sat on their helmets and listened to a general apologize. The general wept. The soldiers wept. And a soldier from Mishawaka, Indiana, who had been struck in a hospital tent, lived twenty-seven more years and said one sentence about the man who struck him. The sentence is not an explanation, and it is not a defense. It is a memory, and it is the memory of a man who saw George Patton at his worst and still called him a great general. The men who drove him and served him and were punished by him saw the same things, and they found them unusual, and they were right.

The story of what the troops found unusual about General Patton is, in the end, a story about seeing a man clearly. The soldiers saw the voice and the scowl and the profanity and the pistols and the claims of other lives, and they saw the apology and the tears and the restored rank. They did not resolve the contradiction, and neither does the record. What the record does is preserve the details: the olive grove near Randazzo, the three thousand men on their helmets, the two medical tents, the soldier from Mishawaka, the twenty-seven years, the one sentence. Those details are the story, and the story is what the men found unusual, and what they found unusual was a man who was not one thing but many, and who remained, in their memory, a great general.