The question of who was considered golf’s most beautiful woman has followed the sport for more than half a century, and the names most often attached to that label — Laura Baugh and Jan Stephenson — tell a story far more complicated than any beauty contest. Both arrived on the LPGA Tour in the 1970s as celebrated young stars, both were marketed relentlessly for their looks, and both were compared to one another constantly. Yet their records on the course diverged sharply, and that divergence became one of the most revealing case studies in the history of women’s professional golf. The story begins in the summer of 1977, when the best players in the world gathered at Hazeltine for the US Women’s Open, and a remark from a USGA official laid bare exactly how the sport’s gatekeepers viewed its female stars.

The Hazeltine course that year was brutal, and many players complained it was unfair. Frank Hannigan of the USGA had little sympathy. He said the best thing that could happen to the women’s tour would be for Laura Baugh to win in a halter top, no matter how high her score. The comment was blunt, but it captured the prevailing logic of the era: in the eyes of the men who ran golf, a photogenic winner was worth more than a precise one. Laura Baugh had never won a professional tournament. In their view, she did not have to. At sixteen she had become the youngest US Amateur champion in history. At seventeen she turned professional. In 1973 she was named Rookie of the Year, and Golf Digest declared her the most beautiful golfer in the sport. That same week at Hazeltine, another young woman carried her own label. Sports Illustrated called Jan Stephenson the sex goddess of the tour. She was an Australian who had been named Rookie of the Year one season after Laura, and she gave reporters a line that sounded like a direct answer to Hannigan: I want everyone to know that I want to be the best, not just the prettiest. Then she went out and finished fourth.
Two young women, two rookie titles in consecutive years, two faces the tour wanted to sell to the world. On paper they were mirror images — same era, same tour, same promise. Ten years later their numbers were not even in the same league. Laura and Jan were not the first, however. Long before them, golf had already learned that a pretty face could sell tickets. In 1951 a Time magazine correspondent surveyed the brand-new women’s tour and wrote that apart from the Bauer sisters, the professionals were a sexless, boring bunch. The Bauer sisters were Alice and Marlene, two girls from a small town called Eureka in South Dakota. Their father Dave fell in love with golf at thirty and leased the local nine-hole course. He put a cut-down club in Marlene’s hands when she was three years old. Before the women’s tour even existed, his daughters played exhibition matches across the country. In 1950 both sisters were among the thirteen women who founded the LPGA, and they became its first glamour girls. In 1952 they appeared on Wheaties boxes. While other players wore long skirts, the Bauers kept theirs short. On a tour of Australia in 1953, the simple act of wearing shorts on the course caused a sensation. Fans came to see them, magazines wrote about them. The formula was set in the very first season: put beautiful women in front of the cameras, and the crowds will follow.

Twenty-five years later, a new commissioner took that formula and pushed it further than anyone had before. In 1975 the LPGA hired Ray Volpe as its first commissioner. What he inherited was close to bankruptcy. Total prize money for the entire tour was about 1.5 million dollars. A year later, the winner of the US Women’s Open took home just 9,054 dollars. Volpe believed the tour needed more than better golf — it needed stars, and he knew exactly what kind. He went to Jan with an offer and a condition. If she would only win, he told her, he could really market her. In 1976 she won her first LPGA title in Naples. Volpe delivered the news in person: you are now the face of the LPGA Tour. The following year Jan posed for the cover of Sport Magazine’s Sex and Sports issue in a thin pink shirt. Within weeks she was one of the most famous athletes in the world. Laura was marketed just as intensively through a different route. She signed with IMG, the sports agency founded by Mark McCormack. She appeared in commercials for Ultra-Brite toothpaste that opened with a line that became famous across America: Hey Laura Baugh, how’s your love life? Her contracts included Ford, Suzuki, Rolex and Colgate-Palmolive. Her pin-up calendar sold so well in Japan that she was arguably more popular there than at home. One of these women had won before the tour made her its face. The other had not. For the moment, that seemed not to matter.
If money is the measure, the answer appears simple. In 1976, her fourth year on tour, Laura reportedly earned 270,000 dollars from endorsement contracts. She would have had to play nine full years of tournaments to earn that on the course. Set that figure against the US Women’s Open: in the same year, the national champion received 9,054 dollars. Laura’s endorsement income in a single season was nearly thirty times the prize money for winning the biggest event in women’s golf, and she had never won anything. Jan built her own business alongside the fairway. Her golf ball sponsor, Dunlop, produced a calendar featuring her. Magazines wanted her, sponsors wanted her, and tournament directors wanted her in the field, because when she played, the people came. The strategy worked for everyone. Under Volpe, the tour’s total prize money rose from about 1.5 million dollars to 6.4 million by 1982. More tournaments, more sponsors, more attention. The women once described as a lackluster group were now selling calendars on two continents. Beauty had saved the tour. At that level, Laura and Jan stood side by side, and Laura may even have been ahead. But money is only half the story. The other half is written on the leaderboard, and there the story splits in two.

The gap is best seen by comparing them directly. In 1979 Laura came as close to a professional victory as she ever would. At the Mayflower Classic she finished the regulation round tied for the lead and went to a sudden-death playoff. On the second extra hole, Hollis Stacy took the title. Laura went home without a trophy once again. It was a familiar ending. Six years earlier, in her very first tournament as a professional, she had entered the final round with a two-shot lead, shot a 75 and finished tied for second. Close, but never quite there. That became the hallmark of her career. In August 1981 Jan came to the Mary Kay Classic in Dallas. She needed no playoff. She finished the tournament with a 64, totaling 198 strokes, and won by eleven shots. She was the first woman in LPGA history to finish a 54-hole tournament under 200 strokes, and her margin set an LPGA record for a 54-hole event that Annika Sorenstam would only match in 2002. Then came December 1983, and this time they appeared in the same field. The JC Penney Mixed Team Classic paired an LPGA player with a man from the PGA Tour. Jan played alongside a young Fred Couples. Together they shot 264 and broke the tournament record by four strokes. A record crowd of 17,500 came to the final round, most of them to see the glamour team. Laura was in the same field, playing beside her husband, Bobby Cole. They were the only married couple ever to compete in that event. They finished far down the leaderboard.
The players who saw them every week noticed the difference. Nancy Lopez called Jan the player who worked hardest on her game. Joanne Carner said Laura lacked grit. One of them always came close and then let it slip away. The other was on her way to achieving something that would eventually place her among the greats of the game. Jan went on to win major championships, including the LPGA Championship and the US Women’s Open, and finished her career with more than a dozen tour victories. Laura, for all her fame and all her commercial success, never won an LPGA event. The woman the sport had crowned most beautiful was, by the cold logic of the scoreboard, the one who never lifted a trophy.

That contrast has shaped how the question is answered even today. When people ask who was considered golf’s most beautiful woman, they are usually recalling a specific moment — the covers, the calendars, the toothpaste commercials, the halter-top remark at Hazeltine — rather than a settled title. The label was never official. It was bestowed by magazines, by sponsors and by tour officials who understood that beauty sold tickets in an era when women’s golf was fighting for survival. Laura Baugh was the archetype of that strategy: a prodigy at sixteen, a professional at seventeen, a marketing phenomenon whose face appeared on products and posters around the world. Jan Stephenson was its most successful product: a player who was marketed as a glamour figure but who also delivered on the course, winning majors and setting records that stood for decades. Both women were, in different ways, asked to carry a tour on their looks. Only one of them was also allowed to be measured by her score.
The history matters because it exposes an uncomfortable truth about how women’s sports were promoted for decades. The Bauer sisters wore shorts and drew crowds. Laura Baugh signed endorsement deals worth nearly thirty times the prize money of the national championship. Jan Stephenson posed for a magazine cover and became one of the most famous athletes in the world. None of this was accidental. It was a deliberate commercial strategy, and it worked: prize money on the LPGA Tour more than quadrupled in a few short years. But the strategy also created a trap. Players who were marketed for their appearance were often judged by it, and the ones who could not convert attention into victories were left with fame but no trophies. The numbers tell a different story than the headlines did. Laura Baugh earned millions and won nothing. Jan Stephenson earned fame and won everything she had set out to win. The tour sold beauty, but the leaderboard kept its own accounting.

Today the question of who was golf’s most beautiful woman is less a factual matter than a reflection of the era that asked it. Laura Baugh and Jan Stephenson remain the two names most associated with the label, and their careers remain the clearest illustration of what it cost to carry it. One was celebrated for her looks and never won a professional tournament. The other was marketed as a glamour figure and became a major champion. Both were young women asked to sell a sport to a public that was not yet ready to watch them purely for their golf. Their story is not really about beauty at all. It is about what the sport chose to value, what it chose to reward, and what it took for a woman to be remembered as a winner rather than merely a face. The answer to the question, in the end, depends entirely on who is doing the remembering — and on whether they are looking at the magazine cover or at the scorecard.